"Peer Eye for the New Guy" is catchy but not suitable for this specific application. None of us were peers (OK, Gunther and Zig are knights, but they were only peripherally involved in the "decorating" phase of the plan. They were mostly in on the "distraction" portion of the plan...), and Zartan has been around for over a decade which makes him somewhat less than "new."

However, for gently correcting the new and awful, that doesn't sound like bad SCA-style Shtick.